Skip to main content

The Chillicothe Voice

Once Upon a Time in Chillicothe, IL – The Story of Webb’s Inn, Part 2

Aug 27, 2025 04:05PM ● By Brian L. Fislar

Golden Anniversary of Gilbert and Olive Webb
On September 11, 1942, Gilbert and Olive Webb celebrated a remarkable milestone—their 50th wedding anniversary. The celebration was held at their beloved Webb’s Inn, where they welcomed friends, family, and community members for an open house event. No formal invitations were sent out, as the Webbs wanted everyone to feel welcome.

More than 400 guests attended, filling the inn with love, laughter, and heartfelt congratulations. The entire home was adorned with colorful bouquets of roses, chrysanthemums, and gladioli, filling the air with a festive fragrance. Olive wore a beautiful soldier blue lace gown, with a corsage made from war stamps wrapped in golden ribbons, a gift from the Peoria chapter of the Daughters of the American Revolution (D.A.R.), to which she belonged.

Family and friends from near and far traveled to Chillicothe for the event. The couple’s children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren were all present, making it a heartwarming family reunion. Out-of-town guests included longtime friends from Ohio, Indiana, and Peoria. Dinner was served to close family and a few special guests, while others stopped by throughout the day to sign the guest book, offer congratulations, and enjoy refreshments.

The anniversary was a shining moment on Chillicothe’s social calendar. Local newspapers covered the event, describing it as one of the most joyous gatherings of the year. The celebration reflected the couple’s enduring love, hard work, and the respect they had earned throughout Central Illinois. As one guest put it, “If anyone deserves to be celebrated, it’s Gilbert and Olive Webb.”

The Sale of Webb’s Inn
After 25 years of hard work and hospitality, Gilbert and Olive Webb decided it was time to step back and enjoy a well-deserved retirement. In 1945, they sold Webb’s Inn to three new owners — Dean A. Claycomb, James Sweeney, and LeRoy Austin. It wasn’t an easy decision for the Webbs. The inn had become more than just a business; it was their home and a symbol of everything they had built together. But as the demands of running the inn grew and their age advanced, they knew it was time to pass the torch.

Claycomb, Sweeney, and Austin weren’t just any buyers. They were World War II veterans with big dreams and fresh energy. From the start, they made it clear they wanted to honor the Webb legacy. Their plan wasn’t to change everything but to build on what was already great. They talked about modernizing a few parts of the inn while keeping its historic charm intact. Most importantly, they promised to keep the same high level of service, famous chicken dinners, and welcoming atmosphere that had made Webb’s Inn a community treasure.

Word of the sale spread quickly, bringing both memories of the past and curiosity about the future. People were eager to see what the new owners would bring to the table. Local newspapers covered the story, emphasizing the new owners’ commitment to keeping the spirit of Webb’s Inn. For many, it felt like a moment of continuity, not change. With so many relieved to know they’re going to keep things going just the way the Webbs would have wanted.

But just as the town was ready for a new chapter, tragedy struck. Before the new owners could fully realize their vision for the inn, fate had other plans.

The Fire of 1947
On February 22, 1947, Chillicothe woke up to devastating news—Webb’s Inn was on fire. It all started when a neighbor spotted the flames, but by the time firefighters arrived, it was already an uphill battle. Crews from Chillicothe, Peoria, and Lacon worked together to fight the blaze, but things took a turn for the worse when one of the fire trucks broke down due to wartime wear and tear. Despite their best efforts, they couldn’t save the historic inn. By the end of the day, it was gone—reduced to ashes and rubble.

Thankfully, no one was hurt, but the emotional and financial impact on the community was undeniable. The town mourned the loss of one of its most cherished landmarks. For many, it felt like they were losing a part of their own family history. Webb’s Inn had been more than a place to eat—it was a gathering spot, a place where stories were shared, and memories were made. Its absence left a hole in the heart of Chillicothe that would not be filled anytime soon.

The Aftermath and Passing of Olive and Gilbert Webb
It’s hard to put into words how much Chillicothe felt the loss of Olive Hallam Webb. Just one month after the fire that destroyed Webb’s Inn, on March 25, 1947, Olive passed away. Many people believed the heartbreak of losing the inn played a role in her declining health. Her passing marked the end of an era, but her spirit continued to live on through the community she had touched.

The town felt her absence deeply. People shared stories about Olive’s kindness, her legendary Christmas parties, and her dedication to making every guest feel special at Webb’s Inn. Friends, family, and even former patrons paid their respects at her funeral, which was attended by people from all levels of society. Her legacy of love, compassion, and hard work left an indelible mark on Chillicothe.

After Olive’s passing, Gilbert Webb continued to live in Chillicothe. Without Olive by his side, things felt different, but he stayed connected to the relationships they had built over the years. He often shared stories about the early days of Webb’s Inn and the journey he and Olive had taken together from Ohio to Illinois. Gilbert was known as a steady, reliable presence in the community. Even as his health began to decline, his love for Chillicothe never wavered.

On April 12, 1952, Gilbert Webb passed away quietly, reuniting with Olive at last. His passing marked the close of a remarkable chapter in Chillicothe’s story, but the legacy of Gilbert and Olive Webb lived on. Their influence wasn’t just about great food and hospitality—it was about community, love, and the belief that with hard work and heart, you could build something truly lasting.

Imprints of Excellence
The legacy of Gilbert and Olive Webb is about so much more than their famous chicken dinners. Their generosity, especially Olive’s Christmas parties for kids who had little to nothing, left a mark that’s still felt today. Their story lives on in family conversations, local newspaper clippings, and the memories of anyone lucky enough to have dined at Webb’s Inn.

Even though the inn itself is gone, its spirit is still alive in Chillicothe. People still talk about the warmth of Olive Webb’s hospitality, the irresistible aroma of fried chicken, and the heartache that swept the town the day of the fire in 1947. Through old photos, family stories, and community events, Webb’s Inn continues to remind everyone of how much one family can shape an entire town.

For so many in Chillicothe, Webb’s Inn wasn’t just a restaurant — it was a part of their family’s story. People who dined there still recall the cozy glow of the dining room and the meals that tasted like home. Even those who never stepped inside have heard the stories from parents and grandparents who did. It was the spot where birthdays were celebrated, anniversaries were marked, and friendships grew stronger. The legacy of Webb’s Inn isn’t just one of good food — it’s one of love, tradition, and the kind of memories that get passed down from generation to generation.

Where Memories Never Fade
The magic of Webb’s Inn lies not just in its food but in its ability to bring people together. It was a place where diners experienced warmth, laughter, and the comfort of a home away from home. Though the inn is gone, its legacy is woven into the heart of Chillicothe’s story—a fairytale of kindness, perseverance, and community spirit that will be told for generations to come.

Once upon a time, there was a magical place where fried chicken reigned supreme, love was served in every meal, and the echoes of shared laughter never truly faded away.