Founded in June 1938 by Marion Geiger, the business began as Geiger Cash Hardware at 921 2nd Street. Marion brought his experience from his father’s hardware store in Cissna Park, Illinois, and quickly established a reputation for quality and service. Not long after opening, he was approached by John Cotter, founder of True Value, to become a charter member—eventually making Geiger the 33rd store in the dealer-owned cooperative. Even in his later years, Marion remained a familiar face, walking to the store and assisting customers with unwavering dedication.

Today, the store is proudly owned by Tom Geiger and Ann Geiger-Knoll, alongside Maria, Jake, and Ollie Geiger—continuing a family tradition of service that spans generations.

Geiger True Value offers a wide range of products and services designed to meet the needs of both DIYers and professionals. Customers can explore a dedicated Stihl department featuring cutting-edge outdoor power tools, a well-stocked pet department, a curated rental selection, and a full-service paint center with premium paints and stains.

Behind the scenes, the store goes even further—offering expert repair and maintenance services for Stihl equipment, window and screen repair, precision sharpening for mower and chainsaw blades, and custom-cut plexiglass and glass. It’s this combination of products and hands-on expertise that truly sets them apart.

For the Geiger family, doing business in Chillicothe means serving friends, neighbors, and lifelong connections. Their mission has always been simple: help people find solutions and leave with a smile. Whether it’s a quick conversation or solving a complex project challenge, the team takes pride in making every customer’s day a little brighter.

The business also stays deeply involved in the community through donations, sponsorships, and by opening their space to local groups for fundraising and collaboration. By supporting smaller vendors and offering them a place within the store, Geiger True Value helps strengthen the broader local economy.

Over the years, the industry has shifted toward convenience and lower-cost, big-box alternatives. However, Geiger True Value remains committed to preserving the value of local expertise, personalized service, and community connection. Their goal is to continue supporting Chillicothe families—today and for generations to come.

As they approach 90 years in business, one thing remains clear: if you can’t find what you need, the team at Geiger True Value will help you find—or create—a solution. With access to an extensive online catalog and a commitment to customer care, they’re always ready to help you move your project forward.

Stop in and experience the difference of a business that’s built on tradition, service, and community. Geiger True Value Hardware is located at 307 W Walnut Street, Chillicothe, IL and can be reached at 309-274-2860.